A Strong Voice for Croydon Central - Gavin Barwell MP
Help me
Contact me

A wake up call on sentencing
03/04/2011 22:03:00

My former boss, Lord Ashcroft, has published a major piece of research into the opinions of the general public, victims of crime and police officers on crime and the criminal justice system.

80% of police officers, and over 80% of the general public and victims of crime, think sentencing is too lenient.

More than two thirds of the general public and victims of crime believe that rates of reoffending when people are released from prison are high because “sentences are too short and prison life is not hard enough to serve as a deterrent to committing further crimes”; less than a third think it is because “prison does not focus enough on rehabilitating offenders”.

41% of the public and 35% of police officers see rehabilitation as “a hard-headed, practical way of trying to reduce reoffending rates”; 59% of the public and 58% of police officers are more inclined to see it as “a soft option that tries to make excuses for offenders rather than punishing them properly”.

Finally, 57% of the public expected the Coalition to be tougher than the last Labour Government in dealing with crime; only 13% think it is being tougher, 23% say it is less tough and 64% say it is about the same.

For what it is worth, I agree with the majority view that sentencing is too lenient and life in prison not tough enough (I was at a conference the other day where an ex-offender referred to doing time as "government holiday"). But I disagree with the majority's sceptism about rehabilitation - many offenders have drug, alcohol and/or mental health problems and Ken Clarke is quite right to argue that releasing them with trying to address those problems makes little sense.

The problem with this debate is that these two policies - tougher sentencing plus a tougher regime in prisons on the one hand, rehabilitation on the other - are often presented as mutually exclusive alternatives. They are not.

The primary function of prison should be to get dangerous criminals off our streets and, without treating them inhumanely, to ensure that the time they serve is a proper punishment for what they have done and deters them and others from offending in the future. But getting them off drugs and/or alcohol, treating any mental health problems they have and giving them the skills to earn an honest living on the outside is not a soft alternative to this.

Crime is the number one issue in my constituency. The Government needs to make the case more effectively for the good things it is doing on rehabilitation, but it needs to change its approach to sentencing where, as this research shows, it is out of step with the views of those who elected it.

Comment on this blog


Readers' Comments

On 04/04/2011 10:27:00 Simon wrote:
I agree with what you (and Ken Clarke) say about sentencing and rehabilitation, but I would add two additional points:

1. I don't believe that every individual sentenced should have a longer sentence but I do agree that some individuals should serve longer based on their crimes, the motives, repeat offenders etc so I would suggest a better sentencing range rather than just make all sentences longer. I would also suggest that this gets properly reflected in the "totality" sentencing principle.

2. Whatever is put in place for rehabilitation should also be fully available for those in need who have not offended. That way you can avoid some people feeling that they have to turn to crime in the first place, or worse, feeling so desperate that they turn to crime just to get on a skills training programme!

On 05/04/2011 13:01:00 Tony Martin wrote:
I agree with most of this blog entry but I would like to say that work ethics rather than skills would be more appropriate.

If you give criminals opportunities not easily available to people on the outside it sets the wrong example to vulnerable young people leaving school with little or no qualifications, try and get a dead end job or break the law get away with it for a while get caught and get a degree.




 More Blog Posts
Thank you
  Read Story
My concession speech after the 2017 General Election
  Read Story
Today is polling day - and why I hope you'll support me at the polls
  Read Story
Five reasons to vote Conservative
  Read Story
Howler at the hustings
  Read Story
Campaigning suspended
  Read Story
Funding care for the elderly while making sure people who have worked hard can pass something on to their kids or grandchildren
  Read Story
Opposing Labour's plans for intensification zones in Shirley and Forestdale and to build on the Green Belt/Metropolitan Open Land
  Read Story
Labour’s misleading leaflet on school funding
  Read Story
Fox hunting
  Read Story

Full list of blog posts here

Gavin Barwell, 133 Wickham Road, CR0 8TE, Tel  020 8663 8741      © Gavin Barwell  2019       Promoted by Ian Parker on behalf of Gavin Barwell, both at 36 Brighton Road, Purley, CR8 2LG