A Strong Voice for Croydon Central - Gavin Barwell MP
Help me
Contact me

Balls tries to re-write history
31/01/2011 08:51:00

I was listening to Ed Balls on the Andrew Marr show yesterday and was staggered to hear him say that in the run-up to the recession the UK didn't have a structural deficit (a gap between what the government spends in a given year and what it raises in tax after adjusting to take account of where the economy is in the economic cycle).

The question of who is to blame for the current structural deficit is obviously highly politically sensitive. Mr Balls wants you to believe that it is all the bankers fault. Our case is that Labour were running a structural deficit for years before the recession and it was this - combined with the necessary action they took during the recession - that led to the record structural deficit that we are facing now. If they had been running a surplus - putting money aside for a raining day as they should have been doing during a period of sustained economic growth - the structural deficit now would be significantly lower.

When I got into work this morning I decided to check for myself. I found a note from the House of Commons Library dated 17th June 2010 - which cites its sources as the Office for National Statistics, the Treasury and the Office for Budget Responsibility - which shows that the UK had a structural deficit in every year from 2001/2 to 2009/10 ie in every year of the previous government once it stopped sticking to the spending plans of the previous Conservative government.

For your information, the figures (they are given as a percentage of Gross Domestic Product ie the size of the UK economy) are:

2001/2 0.2%

2002/3 1.9%

2003/4 2.6%

2004/5 3.1%

2005/6 2.8%

2006/7 2.3%

2007/8 2.6%

2008/9 6.4%

2009/10 8.8%

So it looks like about a third of the structural deficit was there before the recession and was clearly Labour's fault - they chose, year after year, to spend more than they were raising. The remaining two thirds was caused by the recession. To what extent that was caused by the greed of bankers, a failure of regulation by government both at home or abroad, many of us seeking to live beyond our means or a combination of all three is a debate for another day. But at least some of the blame does lie with Gordon Brown and his key advisers Ed Balls and Ed Miliband.

Comment on this blog



 More Blog Posts
Friday night's attack on a 17 year-old asylum seeker
  Read Story
Reflections on yesterday's attack
  Read Story
IVF services in Croydon
  Read Story
Government backs upgrade of London to Brighton railway and refuses to fund BML2 concept that would be bad news for Addiscombe in particular
  Read Story
Spot the difference
  Read Story
Second interim report on Croydon tram crash
  Read Story
Fixing our broken housing market.
  Read Story
Government provides £14m for refurbishment of Fairfield Halls and redevelopment of College Green.
  Read Story
Southern Rail latest update
  Read Story
How I will vote on the EU (Notification of Withdrawal) Bill
  Read Story

Full list of blog posts here

Gavin Barwell, House of Commons, SW1A 1AA, Tel  020 8660 0491      © Gavin Barwell  2017       Promoted by Ian Parker on behalf of Gavin Barwell, both at 36 Brighton Road, Purley, CR8 2LG